Simple visa guides, no legal jargon
Back to All Resources
A plain-English walkthrough of Form I-589 (Application for Asylum and for Withholding of Removal): eligibility, deadlines, the five protected grounds, documents to include, the process after filing, and what comes next.
David A. Keller, Esq.
Form I-589 is used to apply for asylum in the United States. It is also used to request withholding of removal and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT) in certain situations.
This guide explains what the form is, who may qualify, what information is typically required, and what to expect after you file.
Important: This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Asylum is highly fact-specific. If you are considering applying, consult a qualified immigration attorney for advice tailored to your circumstances.
Form I-589 is the Application for Asylum and for Withholding of Removal. It is filed with USCIS in many 'affirmative asylum' cases and can also be used in removal proceedings (often referred to as 'defensive asylum'), depending on posture and eligibility.
The form collects identity and biographic details, immigration history, information about family members, and the factual basis for the asylum claim.
Asylum eligibility generally turns on whether you can show past persecution or a well-founded fear of future persecution if returned to your home country.
A key requirement is that the harm (or threatened harm) is connected to one of the protected grounds defined by U.S. immigration law.
To qualify for asylum, the persecution you experienced (or fear) must be 'on account of' at least one of the five protected grounds:
Note: The 'nexus' requirement—proving the connection between the harm and a protected ground—is often one of the most heavily scrutinized parts of an asylum case.
Persecution can include serious harm or threats of serious harm. It is more than generalized hardship or discrimination, and it typically involves severe mistreatment or credible threats that rise to a serious level.
Evidence can include personal declarations, medical records, police reports, witness statements, and country conditions documentation depending on the facts.
A well-founded fear generally requires both a genuine (subjective) fear and an objectively reasonable basis for that fear based on the facts and country conditions.
Applicants often support this with consistent testimony and corroborating documents, including reports on conditions in the country of origin.
'Membership in a particular social group' (PSG) is one of the most complex protected grounds. A PSG claim typically involves defining a group that is recognized as distinct in society and tied to the reason for persecution.
Examples commonly discussed in asylum analysis can include:
Practical tip: PSG definition and supporting evidence should be handled carefully. Small wording differences can change how the claim is evaluated.
Many applicants must file for asylum within one year of arriving in the United States. Missing the one-year filing deadline can have serious consequences.
Certain exceptions may apply, depending on the facts (for example, changed or extraordinary circumstances).
Deadline risk: If you are near (or past) the one-year mark, you should speak with counsel immediately to assess deadline strategy and any possible exception arguments.
Filing Form I-589 typically involves preparing the application, drafting a detailed personal statement, compiling supporting evidence, and submitting the package according to the correct filing instructions for your case type and jurisdiction.
Form I-589 requests background information, addresses, immigration and travel history, details about your family, and the core narrative of why you are seeking asylum.
Consistency matters. Your written statement, supporting documents, and later interview testimony should align on key facts such as dates, locations, and major events.
Supporting evidence can strengthen an asylum claim by corroborating your identity, experiences, and country conditions. What to include depends heavily on your specific facts.
Evidence quality: Not every case has official documents. Where documents are unavailable, clear explanation and alternative corroboration can be important.
After filing, you may receive a receipt notice and then be scheduled for biometrics (fingerprints) and, in many cases, an asylum interview.
Processing times vary significantly by year, location, and case factors. Some cases move quickly; others take much longer.
Many asylum applicants seek work authorization while their case is pending by applying for an Employment Authorization Document (EAD) when eligible.
Note: EAD timing and eligibility can be impacted by procedural posture, delays, and other case factors. Confirm current requirements before filing.
International travel while an asylum case is pending can carry risks, especially travel to the country of claimed persecution. Some applicants seek advance parole or other authorization depending on circumstances.
Travel risk: Do not assume travel is safe for your case. Consult counsel before any international travel to avoid triggering complications or adverse inferences.
Outcomes and next steps depend on whether you filed affirmatively with USCIS or defensively in immigration court. In some situations, a case may be referred to immigration court for removal proceedings; in others, different relief or appeals may be considered.
Next steps: If you receive a denial or referral, act quickly. Deadlines and options can be time-sensitive.
Some individuals who are granted asylum may later become eligible to apply for lawful permanent residence (a green card) after meeting the applicable requirements and timelines.
Eligibility for adjustment of status depends on the specific facts, current rules, and any potential bars that may apply.
Costs can include document gathering, translations, copying/mailing, and (if you hire counsel) attorney fees. Government filing fees can change over time and may vary depending on related applications.
Attorney fees vary widely based on case complexity, procedural posture, deadlines, and the amount of evidence and briefing required.
If you are comparing options, focus on experience in asylum matters, clarity of scope, and how evidence and declarations are handled.
Government fee structures can change. Confirm the latest instructions and fee requirements for any connected filings (such as biometrics or work authorization) before submitting.
Support: Asylum cases are document-heavy and credibility-driven. If you want help building a coherent narrative, organizing evidence, and preparing for interview/court, talk with an experienced immigration attorney.
If you're considering asylum, start with a clear plan and a complete record of your facts.
We can help you evaluate eligibility, deadlines, evidence, and interview preparation—so you file with a clear plan and a consistent record.
If you have questions about timelines, eligibility, or what evidence to include, an attorney can help you assess risk and build a filing strategy based on your situation.
Schedule Your Free Discovery Call
Take the first step toward resolving your legal challenges. Book a friendly meet-and-greet to get to know each other (no legal advice at this stage). However, if you’re ready for tailored guidance, schedule a direct legal consultation instead.
We’re here to support you every step of the way!
Get in Touch with Us
300 Main Street, 1st Floor Worcester, MA 01608
Links
Monday - Friday | 9AM to 5PM
Saturday | Appointment Only
Sunday | Closed
Disclaimer:
In accordance with rules established by the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, this site must be labeled “advertising.” It is designed to provide general information for clients and those browsing our firm’s website and should not be construed as legal advice, or legal opinion on any specific facts or circumstances. This website is designed for general information only. The information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship.
Powered by AG InfoTech
